
Blog
What to Do If Your Ontario Employer Refuses to Accommodate Your Disability

In Ontario, employers have a legal obligation to accommodate employees who are suffering from a disability. Your employer is legally required to adjust your job to fit your medical needs. This may include changing your work schedule, providing specialized equipment, or moving your work location.
Unfortunately, many employers fail to accommodate their employees. They may refuse to provide accommodation, cause unnecessary delays, or offer an inadequate response to the disability request.
If your employer has failed to accommodate your disability, or if you are being pressured to quit, disciplined, or terminated because of your medical condition, you should understand your rights. A disability lawyer can help you navigate this situation.
What Are the Signs Your Employer Is Failing to Accommodate Your Disability?
If you feel that your employer is not accommodating your disability, refer to the two-duty accommodation test under the Ontario Human Rights Code. Failing either duty is discrimination. Ontario employers typically fail the first duty:
- The employer’s procedural duty is to engage with your accommodation request by asking the right questions, gathering medical information, considering alternatives, or communicating in writing. Failing to give any thought or consideration to the issue of accommodation is a breach of the Code.
Common procedural-failure signs are:
- No return-to-work meeting
- No written response to the accommodation request
- Relying on outdated medical information without asking for an update
- Not discussing alternatives
- The employer’s substantive duty is to provide accommodations, particularly in changing your duties, schedules, equipment, location, or workload to remove the barrier to access.
Common substantive-failure signs are:
- Indefinite unpaid leave instead of a role change
- Flat refusals because “they can’t”
- Offering an accommodation that is only convenient for the employer, not for you
Additionally, mental health disabilities require a duty to inquire. An employer should be aware of the relationship between performance issues and a possible disability before making a decision that would negatively affect the employee.
If your employer is showing signs of failing their procedural or substantive duty to accommodate your disability, book a confidential consultation before responding to or signing anything.
What Does Ontario Law Require Your Employer to Do for a Disability?
Most employers ignore Ontario’s accommodation rules under the Code.
Section 5(1) of the Human Rights Code of Ontario states that you have the right to be treated equally in employment without discrimination due to your disability. Section 11 also ensures that employers cannot ignore your rights for their own convenience.
Section 17 states that this right is not violated if you cannot perform essential workplace duties. However, Section 17(2) supports your rights by stating that the employer must still consider the accommodation to find the employee incapable and whether it would cause undue hardship.
Under Section 34, you have one year to file at the Tribunal from the most recent incident of discrimination.
Can Your Employer Demand an Independent Medical Examination (IME)?
Your employer can order an Independent Medical Examination (IME) by a doctor of its choosing, but it must be justified. An unreasonable IME demand is unlawful, and refusing it does not forfeit your accommodation rights. It must have a “reasonable and bona fide basis” to question the adequacy or reliability of the employee’s own medical information.
Employers with 50+ employees must also have written individual-accommodation plans and workplace-emergency-response procedures.
Our Ontario employment lawyers can assess and advise you on your rights related to accommodation requests and any IME demanded.
What Is Undue Hardship Under Ontario’s Human Rights Code?
Undue hardship is the point where your employer no longer has to accommodate you — it is the legal limit on how far they have to go.
Under Section 11(2), undue hardship consists of three factors:
- Costs: Your employer must show facts, figures, scientific data, or expert opinion to support this claim.
- Outside funding: Your employer must show whether outside sources of funding, such as grants, insurance, government programs, or shared funding within the organization could cover the accommodation cost.
- Health and safety: If an accommodation creates health and safety risks, your employer must show that the risk cannot be reduced or eliminated through other reasonable measures.
Employers cannot claim undue hardship based on the following:
- Business inconvenience
- Impact on employee morale
- Third-party and customer preferences
- Collective agreement provisions
Most undue-hardship claims fail due to employers refusing to engage with the accommodation process.
What’s New in Ontario Disability Accommodation Law in 2026?
Since 2024, there have been three new developments for employees with accommodation requests:
- Non-union employees can sue for constructive dismissal in civil court for failure to accommodate. To raise such claims, the employer’s failure to accommodate must show a pattern of conduct indicating that they no longer intend to be bound by the contract.
- Accommodation and reprisal applications will stay active past the employer’s preliminary motions.
- The Tribunal is no longer using the historical $10,000 to $20,000 as a ceiling. These decisions are important when considering negotiating with your employer about disability-related accommodations.
How Long Does Your Employer Have to Keep Accommodating You?
There is no fixed time limit for how long an employer must accommodate a disability. The employer’s duty to accommodate only ends when the employee cannot fulfill basic employment obligations for the foreseeable future, and only after the employer has already attempted to make accommodations.
Long absences alone do not end the duty:
- Naccarato v. Costco: the employee was terminated due to inability to return to work and frustrating the contract due to his 5-year absence. The Court held that Costco wrongfully terminated the employee, as medical evidence did not indicate the employee’s inability to return to work, and was not confirmed through follow-ups with the doctor.
- Ciszkowski v. Canac: the employee on long-term disability leave for 2 years was constructively dismissed after significant role reduction. The Court reasoned that the employee did not frustrate the contract at the time of the constructive dismissal since prolonged disability is not the same as full disability or an inability to return to work. There was no post-termination medical evidence indicating such either.
- A v. Great Atlantic: The employee’s disability was due to a workplace injury, leading to reduced working hours and eventual termination. The Court ruled that the employee’s medical condition did not frustrate the contract, and that lengthy absences were considered.
Can Your Employer Fire You for Asking for Disability Accommodation?
No, your employer cannot fire you for simply asking for disability accommodation. To claim an act of discrimination, you must provide the following:
- Protected characteristic
- Experienced an adverse impact
- The protected characteristic was a factor in experiencing the impact
However, there are exceptions:
- If the employer proves that accommodation would cause undue hardship with objective evidence
- If the accommodation leads to the employee frustrating the contract
- The employer proves that the reason for termination was documented and existed before the accommodation request (e.g., performance issues, documented business restructuring, etc.)
Firing you for raising the request can also be reprisal under Section 8.
If your termination came within weeks of your request and your employer has not documented an unrelated cause, book a confidential consultation to get advice before signing anything.
Consult an Employment Lawyer if Your Ontario Employer Refuses to Accommodate Your Disability
If your Ontario employer has refused, ignored, or dragged out a disability accommodation request — or fired you after one — book a confidential consultation before signing anything. Our employment lawyers at Roberts & Obradovic Law will run the two-duty test on your facts, calculate what you may be owed, and determine whether the Tribunal or Court is the right forum.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to share my diagnosis, or just my limitations?
Generally just functional limitations and restrictions, not the diagnosis. An employer can require an Independent Medical Examination (IME) to assess your limitations only with a reasonable, bona fide basis to question your doctor’s information. Refusing a baseless IME demand does not forfeit your accommodation rights.
How long is the deadline to file with the Human Rights Tribunal?
One year from the last incident of discrimination, under section 34 of the Ontario Human Rights Code. Court actions for wrongful dismissal carry a separate two-year limitation under the Limitations Act, 2002.
Can I sue for constructive dismissal if my employer didn’t accommodate me?
Yes, a non-unionized employee can sue in civil court for constructive dismissal if the lack of accommodation creates a frustrating work environment.
What does undue hardship NOT include?
An employer cannot refuse an accommodation just because it is an inconvenience, bothers other staff, goes against client preferences, or conflicts with a union contract.
Can my employer demand I see their doctor instead of mine?
Sometimes. Your employer must give you proper reasons as to why they are doubting the medical information you are providing. Without strong reasons, an Independent Medical Examination demand may be unlawful.
About the Author
Categories
Contact Us
Call us at (647) 724-5179 or
send a message below




